l'isle-aux-grues-grosse ile好玩吗-景点地址图片介绍-八度伴旅网

dmccormick516

My wife and I visited Grosse Ile during the last week in July (2014) and found it to be an excellent trip that was exceptionally presented by the French Canadian Parc Department. The staff on the Island was extremely knowledgeable and fluent in the history of the island and the misery of those who past through the island. I totally agree with the majority of the reviewers who who found this to be worth their time and effort and we came away emotionally moved from this tour. I totally disagree with the only negative comment that this was not an island of hope. The Irish who made up the majority of the refugees had no hope remaining in Ireland and many more would have died had they remained there since the British totally avoided providing any meaningful assistance.I was surprised at the extent of the care and compassion that the Canadians provided for these refugees. The Irish were not abandoned, the Canadians Doctors, Nurses and Religious truly saved scores who would have otherwise expired from their illnesses and starvation. The experience we feel visiting this island could never be articulated or communicated through just reading a book and reviewing photos. A must see for any Irish descendant (American or Canadian) or any present day Canadian who should be proud of the heroic history of their ancestors during this period.

onvoyage_3

Our visit was very interesting especially for history buffs, but it is quite a little investment with the boat over. I'm sure the upkeep is expensive so it's probably reasonable but we really debated whether it was worth it. In the end we're glad we went. This is a really important piece of history that is skimmed over at best in school curriculum.

frohn

Tour very well done and interesting. Guide was extremely knowledgeable and helpful. Good weather helped too.

Brasstess

Very interesting story on the arrival of Irish immigrants. Very will presented and narrated. Must see.

Twistkow

A very moving experience that was brought to life by Pierre Loop (Peter the Wolf as he introduced himself to us). Pierre was passionate about this island and was familiar with all aspects of its history. This made the difference to our tour and to those attending. The history of the island and how the Irish were humanely treated after they had spent considerable time on cargo ships being delivered to the New World was an incredible story itself. The boat ride over (about 30 minutes) was very relaxing. The food offerings are limited so I would recommend that you bring a lunch and enjoy the grounds.

mary19

This is one of the most interesting places we visited in Canada, and certainly the most interesting in Quebec. It was a very moving experience to visit and hear the story of the Irish who passed through this island trying for a better life. Sad how many died. Canada did their best for them.

ohque

The island is a Federal Park that is usually visited with an official guide. During a typical visit you will encounter actors playing real historic characters. You must take a boat to get to the island, from Berthier-sur-Mer near Montmagny or from Quebec City.As the official website warns you, it is likely you will be moved by the story of Grosse Île, due to the human tragedy that happened on the island. You will relive the troubling experience of immigrants who were quarantined here. Thousands of them, mostly Irish, died here! One reviewer rated the experience as very painful. But perhaps we have a duty to remember. And there is beauty also... The location, in the middle of the majestic Saint-Lawrence river, adds an element of intense beauty to the visit, which heightens the emotional experience by being so opposite to the sadness of the events that took place here.

Sinoed

I'll disagree with the previous review that noted that this is a "must see" attraction. To be fair, Parks Canada is doing a great job trying to educate the public about the island and history of immigration for the Irish into the Port of Quebec. Our guide was helpful, knowledgeable and friendly and took time to explain the buildings and their various purposes. Currently although some buildings have been restored many are in various stages of decay which lend a feeling of neglect and loss to the island. Aside from old buildings including decontamination showers, the hospital and the hotels there are also churches, several burial grounds and a celtic cross as a tribute. There are no genealogical records here aside from a small gift shop which sells some books, mostly on the year 1847.To be perfectly clear this was not an island of hope and promise for a new life in Canada. Many Irish died here while waiting to be allowed entry due to overcrowding and disease. There are many places on throughout the island where a feeling of loss, desperation and anguish remain and this is NOT a place to visit if you are sensitive in any form. I wanted to leave very shortly after arriving, couldn't enter buidings and ended up waiting by the docks for most of the afternoon.Apparently this is not an uncommon reaction. One of the tour guides who lives on the Island (which I can't even imagine) said that visitors are often disturbed by Grosse Ile and commented that even she had a hard time being there at first.If you're interested in Grosse Ile, buy a book, read about it and take a look at some old photos. Save yourself the trouble and the heartache of visiting such a sad and lonely place.

GaetanTurgeon

Nous avons visité cette ile le 28 aouut je recommande a toute personne de visiter cette endroit qui est dirigé par parc Canada .La visite est très très bien structurée la qualité des guides dépasse la moyenne de vraie prof..Bravo et marci

491nadyab

Un trésor d'histoire bien caché.... Visite très interessante! Il faudrait faire plus de publicité sur cet endroit pour que plus de gens connaissent l'histoire de grosse Ile.

grosse ile

景点推荐